Who should get the deposit after ending the lease early?

Claim (Side A)

My roommate moved out 3 months early and I had to cover rent out of pocket to avoid eviction. But I found a subtenant for the very last month. Now he wants his half of the deposit back, claiming he wasn't living there. I think I should keep it for the stress and the 2 months I had to cover alone.

No concrete evidence was submitted to the locker.

Cast Your Vote

Judgy Community, who is right?

180 total votes cast

When the timer ends, The Judgy will analyze all evidence and votes to deliver the final impartial verdict.

Juror Arguments (2)

janedoeLurker4/5/2026

I completely agree with Side A. They had every right to keep the deposit after covering rent!

bobsterLurker4/5/2026

Wait, Side B was not living there. Legally Side B might be entitled to their half back, but morally Side A is right.

Comments are paused until Side B presents their defense.